“The greatest enemy of knowledge is not ignorance, it is the illusion of knowledge.”
—Daniel J. Boorstin

Emperor Penguins in Peril from --- Computer Models

JenouvrierJenouvrierIn another brazen attempt to add emperor penguins to the Endangered Species list, a new study published in Nature Climate Change shows dramatic declines in penguin populations by 2100 from too much or too little sea ice. The results are based on computer model projections, which in turn are based on secondary computer models.

Already on the "under consideration" list for inclusion in the US Endangered Species Act, the study concludes that emperor penguins may decline by up to eighty percent due to sea ice concentration (SIC). The study's lead author, Stephanie Jenouvrier, used computer model projections to reach these conclusions.

Satellite data has shown that sea ice around Antarctic has increased in size by twenty percent since imaging of the continent began in 1979. According to this study, though, too much ice requires the penguins to travel further to gather food for their chicks. Too little ice means less krill for the penguins to eat.

In either case, computer models imperil the penguin colonies if either situation occurs. Just as polar bears were added to the Endangered Species list based on computer model projections, this study is taking a page from that successful play-book to add emperor penguins to the list as well.

However, the study is based on computer model projections using predictive forecasts from the IPCC. The latest IPCC AR5 states the following trends regarding Antarctic sea ice (this is from September 2013, emphasis added):

It is very likely that the annual Antarctic sea ice extent increased at a rate of between 1.2 and 1.8% per decade between 1979 and 2012.

The IPCC AR5 states in Chapter 10 on Attribution (emphasis added):

Overall we conclude that there is low confidence in the scientific understanding of the observed increase in Antarctic sea ice extent since 1979, due to the incomplete and competing scientific explanations for the causes of change and low confidence in estimates of internal variability. …[and that] the shortness of the observed record and differences in simulated and observed variability preclude an assessment of whether or not the observed increase since 1979 is inconsistent with internal variability."

In layman's terms, this means Antarctic sea ice has been increasing since 1979 from satellite observations, and that it's too early to make any kind of assessment as to whether this will continue or abate.

Judith Curry, a climatologist who also serves on the NOAA Climate Working Group, notes that,

The increase in Antarctic sea ice is not understood and is not simulated correctly by climate models.

According to the study (emphasis added),

We analyse global population trends of the emperor penguin…under the influence of sea ice conditions projected by coupled climate models assessed in the IPCC…with local, colony-specific, sea ice conditions projected through to the end of the twenty-first century…all populations are projected to be declining. At least two-thirds are projected to have declined by >50% from their current size.

What this means is that using computer models that even the IPCC said were not robust enough to use as predictive tools, Jenouvrier et al used another computer model to project future sea ice decline in its ongoing attempt to get an endangerment finding for the emperor penguin. Dizzy yet?

Concomitant with the publication of this study, Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution, where Jenouvrier is a biologist, announced in a press release, "Emperor penguin populations across Antarctica finds the iconic animals in danger of dramatic declines by the end of the century due to climate change."

As Jenouvrier admits, “Our models take into account both the effects of too much and too little sea ice in the colony area.” In other words, the continent of Antarctica would have to remain in stasis (as is) for the next 100 years for their computer model projections to be remotely wrong.

“Listing the emperor penguin will provide some tools to improve fishing practices of US vessels in the Southern Ocean, and gives a potential tool to help reduce CO2 emissions in the US under the Clear Air and Clean Water Acts,” Jenouvrier said.

In science, this is known as conducting research with an outcome or result already predetermined. It appears this study is nothing more than a transparent attempt to expedite conservation efforts in Antarctica. Though a laudable goal, wrapping it up in the auspices of an actual scientific "study" and then having it published as research is not a happy feat one should be trumpeting.

updated 7/2/14 (typo)

 

Pin it

Comments   

#1 yportbill 2014-07-01 14:40
What about the eagles and other birds killed by wind farms. Lets stop this clean and warming B.S,
Quote | Report to administrator
#2 bob 2014-07-01 15:45
Those damn computer models are now killing off the penguins. They are useless because their predictions are always wrong, and now they are killing animals. They should be banned.
Quote | Report to administrator
#3 Dave Burton 2014-07-01 19:45
Typo alert:

"Satellite data has shown that Antarctica has increased in size by twenty percent since imaging of the continent began in 1979."

...is not quite what you meant. I think you're missing the words "sea ice around" before the word Antarctica, or something like that.
Quote | Report to administrator
#4 amirlach 2014-07-01 20:23
Quote:
What about the eagles and other birds killed by wind farms.
No model exists that can calculate this... So it likely does not ever happen. :o
Quote | Report to administrator
#5 amirlach 2014-07-01 20:25
Quote:
We analyse global population trends of the emperor penguin…under the influence of sea ice conditions projected by coupled climate models assessed in the IPCC…
So they use failed model predictions to make more model predictions... The mind boggles!
Quote | Report to administrator
#6 Typhoon 2014-07-01 21:26
#2 bob 2014-07-01 15:45 wrote:
"Those damn computer models are now killing off the penguins. They are useless because their predictions are always wrong, and now they are killing animals. They should be banned."

Bono [at a concert starts clapping on stage]: "Every time I clap my hands a child in Africa dies."

Some guy in the audience: "Then stop clapping you freaking bastard!"
Quote | Report to administrator
#7 Jim Steele 2014-07-01 22:38
Extinction fears based on horrendous earlier studies. Read Blinded by Beliefs: The Straight Poop on Emperor Penguins landscapesandcycles.net/resilient-emperor-penguin.html
Quote | Report to administrator
#8 Jacob 2014-07-02 06:57
Even the IPCC says not to use their computer models when projecting sea ice levels into the future as they are not robust enough. This is ridiculous.
Quote | Report to administrator
#9 Thomas 2014-07-02 14:44
Quoting Dave Burton:
Typo alert:

"Satellite data has shown that Antarctica has increased in size by twenty percent since imaging of the continent began in 1979."

...is not quite what you meant. I think you're missing the words "sea ice around" before the word Antarctica, or something like that.


All fixed. Thanks for the head's up!
Quote | Report to administrator
#10 R Cannon 2014-07-12 01:13
Not only is the ice model off but so is the heat rejection assumptions of the earth. NASA released a statement a couple years ago to that effect, from satellite data, saying the climate change "alarmists" computer models were not accurate. Also it shows CO2 has much less effect than their models show. So no wonder their models cannot predict the ice formation- global warming is not happening, and in fact cooling may be. www.forbes.com/sites/jamestaylor/2011/07/27/new-nasa-data-blow-gaping-hold-in-global-warming-alarmism/
Quote | Report to administrator
#11 Gerald Wilhite 2014-07-14 21:13
In my opinion, this recent study totally debunks this article:

www.thegwpf.org/antarctic-penguin-census-shows-seabirds-are-thriving/
Quote | Report to administrator

Add comment

Before posting a comment, please read the Terms of Service (click here). Get your own avatar at Gravatar.com. PLEASE report all spam/inappropriate comments using the 'Report to administrator' link. If you find your post gone, it's because you violated the TOS.


Security code
Refresh

4464007
Today
Yesterday
This Week
Last Week
This Month
Last Month
All days
8700
13722
22422
2852703
8700
417039
4464007
Your IP: 50.19.148.56
Server Time: 09-01-2014 16:59:00
Visitors Counter